Weekly Drops. Limited Quantities. Local Pickup/Delivery.
Home Bakery Specializing in Gourmet Cookie Boxes Released Weekly with New Flavors Each Week. Located in Champaign-Urbana.
Shop the Signature Boxes
Each week’s box includes classic favorites like chocolate chunk and frosted sugar, plus whimsical seasonal creations. Baked fresh in small batches.
Spooky Party Platter
This party platter is worth sharing with 16-24 servings and 7 different flavors! You'll get: Purple People Eater x2 Cookies and Scream x2 Kitchen Stink x2 Frosted Sugar Skull x3 Black Widow x3 Pumpkin Sandwich x4 Funfetti Minis x8
Boo Box
This limited edition boo box is curated with flavors full of spooky fun and something for everyone's taste. Perfect to share with the family or a ghostly night alone! The Boo Box includes: Chocolate Chunk x1 Purple People Eater x1 Cookies and Scream x1 Kitchen Stink x1 Frosted Sugar Skull x2 AND YOUR CHOICE OF Black Widow x2 OR Pumpkin Sandwich x2 Put your choice in the notes section when you place your order! No note will default to Black Widow cookies
Meet the Baker
Hi, I'm Starrlee, the baker behind Sugar, Spice & Starlight!
When I made my friends and family cookie boxes for Christmas 2025, I never dreamed that 6 months later I would turn it into a whole business; all the while being a new mom to a sweet tiny baby, but here we are! 🤷♀️
How it Works
Cookies are released in limited quantities weekly. Here's how to get yours.
Be First in Line
Join the club so you can be first to hear about flavor drops, holiday boxes and special releases before they sell out. Receive special promotions only members have access to.
You Get
- ⌛️ Early Access to Drops
- ❗️Pre-order Reminders
- 🎁 Special Promotions